The Hidden Link Between People-Pleasing and Anxiety (And Why Boundaries Aren't Selfish)

You've checked every box. The successful career, the loving relationship, the beautiful home in the right neighborhood. From the outside, your life looks exactly like what you always thought would make you happy. But lately, when you're alone with your thoughts in those quiet moments before sleep or during your morning commute there's this nagging feeling you can't quite shake. A heaviness. An exhaustion that has nothing to do with how many hours you slept. A whisper that keeps asking: Is this really it?

You're not burned out in the traditional sense. You're still getting things done and showing up… performing, if you will. But somewhere along the way, you stopped recognizing yourself. You can't remember the last time you said what you actually thought instead of what you knew would just keep the peace. You've become so good at reading rooms, anticipating needs, and smoothing over tensions that you've lost track of what YOU actually want. And underneath it all? There's anxiety. Constant, humming, exhausting anxiety.

If this sounds familiar, I see you. I get it. And I want you to know something important: You're not dramatic. You're not ungrateful. And you're definitely not alone.

What you're experiencing is the hidden link between people-pleasing and anxiety, a connection that keeps you trapped in a cycle of over-functioning, second-guessing, and feeling perpetually on edge. But here's what I've learned through years of sitting across from clients who share your exact struggle: You're not stuck. You just haven't been given the right tools yet.

The Subtle Dysfunction in "Good Enough" Families

When most people hear about the origins of people-pleasing and anxiety, they expect a dramatic backstory. Abuse. Neglect. Addiction. Obvious trauma. And yes, those experiences absolutely contribute to these patterns. But what nobody talks about, though, is how people-pleasing also develops in families that look perfectly fine from the outside, maybe even families like yours, perhaps.

Maybe your parents weren't emotionally abusive, but they weren't necessarily emotionally available either. They provided everything you needed materially but struggled to attune to your feelings. When you were upset, you heard "you're being too sensitive" or "there's nothing to cry about." Love felt conditional on achievements such as making the honor roll, winning the game, or getting into the right college. Maybe not explicitly, and not because your parents were malicious in any way, but because that's how they understood connection and communicated their values to you.

Or perhaps conflict was avoided at all costs in your home. Difficult emotions were swept under the rug, and anger was never expressed directly. Everyone smiled at dinner while tension hummed beneath the surface. You learned early that to maintain belonging, you needed to stay small, be agreeable, and never rock the boat.

Here's what happens in these environments: You develop an incredibly sophisticated internal radar system. You learn to read micro-expressions, sense shifts in energy, and anticipate needs before they're spoken. These become your superpowers, the skills that make you exceptional at your job, beloved by friends, and the glue that holds your family together.

But these superpowers come with a cost. Because when your nervous system is constantly scanning for threats to connection, it never truly rests. That's where anxiety lives, in that space between who you really are and who you've learned you need to be to stay safe.

Why People-Pleasing and Anxiety Are Inseparable

Think of people-pleasing and anxiety as dance partners who've been moving together for so long, they've forgotten they're two separate entities. They feed each other in a cycle that feels impossible to break.

Here's how it works: Anxiety tells you that disappointing someone is dangerous. Not logically dangerous, per se - you know rationally that your friend won't abandon you if you decline their invitation. But to your nervous system, which was wired in childhood when rejection actually WAS dangerous, it feels life-threatening. So you say yes when you mean no. You agree when you actually disagree. You apologize when you've done literally nothing wrong.

In the moment, people-pleasing provides immediate relief. The other person is happy. The conflict is avoided. Your anxiety quiets, albeit briefly. But then comes the aftermath: the resentment at yourself for not speaking up, the exhaustion from performing instead of being authentic, the growing sense that nobody really knows you because you've spent so long being who everyone needs you to be.

And what does your nervous system learn from this? That anxiety was right to warn you. That you DO need to people-please to stay safe. And so the cycle perpetuates.

This is why people-pleasing and anxiety aren't just related, they're inseparable. The anxiety drives the people-pleasing, and the people-pleasing validates the anxiety. Round and round it goes, year after year, until you find yourself successful, accomplished, and yet utterly depleted.

The Cycle Breaker's Dilemma: Wanting Change Without Losing Connection

If you're reading this and recognizing yourself, you're probably what I call a cycle breaker, someone who wants to do things differently than you have in the past and/or than the generation before you has done in the past. You've looked at the patterns in your behavior and in your family - the emotional unavailability, the conflict avoidance, the conditional love - and decided: It stops with me.

But here's where it gets complicated. Unlike the clear-cut advice to "just cut off toxic people," your situation is more nuanced. Your family isn't overtly toxic. Your relationships aren't abusive. And more importantly, you don't WANT to lose these connections. You love these people. You want them in your life. You maybe just want the dynamic to be a little different.

This is the cycle breaker's dilemma: How do you break generational patterns without breaking generational bonds?

So many resources present this as a binary choice: either continue people-pleasing and stay connected, or set boundaries and lose your family. But that's a false dichotomy. There IS a middle path, a way to honor yourself while maintaining relationships. It's harder than either extreme, and it requires you to tolerate discomfort. But it's possible. And it's the path I help my clients navigate every single day in my Southport practice.

The middle path means accepting that when you change, your relationships will need to renegotiate. Your mother might say "you've changed" (and she's right, you have). Your partner might feel confused by your new boundaries. Your friends might not understand why you can't just "let it go" like you always have.

This discomfort isn't evidence that you're doing something wrong. It's evidence that you're doing something different. And different always feels uncomfortable before it feels right.

Why Boundaries Aren't Selfish (But Feel That Way)

Let's address the belief that's probably running through your mind right now: But isn't it selfish to prioritize my needs over others' wants?

I hear this question all the time from my high-achieving people-pleasers. You've spent your whole life believing that being a good person means putting others first. That boundaries are what selfish people use to justify their callousness. That if you truly cared, you'd sacrifice your comfort for someone else's happiness.

But here's what I need you to understand: Boundaries aren't about prioritizing your needs OVER others' needs. They're about recognizing that your needs matter AS MUCH AS others' needs. Not more. Not less. Equal. (I know, that may be a mind-blowing concept right now).

Think of it this way: When you set a boundary, you're not building a wall to keep people out. You're drawing a property line that shows where you end and someone else begins. This line doesn't create distance, it creates clarity. It allows both people to show up authentically instead of one person constantly shape-shifting to accommodate the other.

The reason boundaries feel selfish is because your nervous system interprets them as dangerous. Remember, you learned early that your safety depended on being accommodating. So when you consider saying no, declining an invitation, or expressing a need, your body floods with anxiety. And your brain, trying to make sense of this physical sensation, creates a story: "I must be doing something wrong. I must be selfish."

But the guilt you feel when setting a boundary isn't proof that the boundary is wrong. It's proof that the boundary is necessary. That guilt is feedback about your conditioning, not your character.

Here's what actually happens when you start setting boundaries in relationships: Initially, there's discomfort. The other person might feel surprised, disappointed, or even hurt. This is the moment where most people-pleasers panic and retreat, thinking "See? I knew this would damage our relationship."

But if you can stay steady, and if you can hold the boundary with compassion while also holding space for the other person's feelings, something remarkable happens. The relationship becomes more honest. More balanced. More sustainable. Because relationships built on one person's constant accommodation aren't actually intimate, they're transactions where one person earns connection through performance.

Real intimacy requires two people who are willing to disappoint each other sometimes. Who can say "I love you AND I'm not available for that." Who understand that conflict isn't a threat to connection, it's an invitation to know each other more deeply.

This doesn't mean every relationship will survive your new boundaries. Some relationships were only working because you were overextending. But the relationships that DO survive? They become infinitely more nourishing. Because the person on the other side finally gets to know the real you, not just the version of you that's been carefully curated for their comfort.

The Emotional Work Nobody Talks About

If you've tried setting boundaries before and found yourself right back in old patterns, it's probably because you focused on the behavior without addressing the emotional foundation. Setting boundaries isn't just about learning to say no, it's about fundamentally shifting your relationship with yourself and others. And that requires emotional work that most resources skip right over.

Grieving the Fantasy

One of the most profound (and painful) parts of breaking people-pleasing patterns is grieving the fantasy of unconditional acceptance. You have to release the hope that if you're just good enough, helpful enough, or accommodating enough, everyone will love you exactly as you are.

This grief is real and deserves space. You're not just changing a behavior, you're mourning a belief system that's kept you company your entire life. The belief that your worth is earned through usefulness. That love is conditional on performance. That if you disappoint someone, you risk losing them forever.

When you start setting boundaries, you discover which relationships were based on genuine connection and which were based on what you could provide. And sometimes, that discovery is heartbreaking. The friend who only calls when she needs something. The family member who guilts you for not being more available. The partner who's uncomfortable when you express needs instead of just meeting theirs.

This isn't failure, it's clarity. Painful clarity, yes. But clarity nonetheless.

Sitting with Others' Disappointment

People-pleasers are expert mood managers. You can sense when someone is upset and immediately jump into fix-it mode. You apologize, explain, soothe, accommodate - anything to return the relationship to equilibrium.

But part of breaking this pattern is learning to sit with other people's disappointment without fixing it. To say no and then (and this is the hardest part, brace yourself)..... to let them be upset about it without rushing to make it better.

This feels excruciating. Your whole body will scream at you to take it back, to apologize, to explain more. Your anxiety will spike. You'll feel like the worst person in the world.

But here's what I want you to know: Their disappointment won't destroy them, and it won't destroy your relationship. What will damage your relationships long-term is continuing to show up inauthentically because you're terrified of anyone ever being unhappy with you.

When you can tolerate someone's disappointment, when you can acknowledge "I understand this is hard for you AND I'm still not available for that,” you teach them something radical: that you're a whole person with your own needs, not an extension of their wants. This is how adult relationships actually work.

Rebuilding Your Identity

Perhaps the most disorienting part of this work is discovering that you don't actually know who you are beneath the people-pleasing. You've spent so long being what others need that when someone asks "What do YOU want?" you draw a blank, “I don’t know, am I supposed to know that, why don’t I know that?”.

This identity crisis is completely normal, and it's actually a sign of progress. It means you're starting to differentiate between your authentic self and the adaptive self you created to stay safe. But living in that in-between space, where you're no longer who you were but not yet fully who you're becoming, feels terrifying.

You might find yourself questioning everything: Your career choice (did you become a lawyer because YOU wanted to, or because it made your parents proud?). Your friendships (do these people know the real you?). Your preferences (do you actually like hosting holiday dinners, or have you just always done it?). Your love of Pop Tarts (do you like Pop Tarts because you truly enjoy Pop Tarts, or because you know your mother would have hated them) - Ok sorry, that last one was a bit of a pop-culture deep cut, but my Gilmore Girls fans will get it.

This questioning isn't a crisis, it's an awakening. And on the other side of it is a life that actually feels like yours.

The Path Forward: Therapy as a Guide, Not a Guru

I've spent this entire article explaining the problem, which might have you thinking: Great, now I understand why I'm stuck. But how do I actually change?

This is where therapy comes in, not as someone telling you what to do, but as a space where you can explore, experiment, and ultimately unlock the wisdom that's already within you.

In my work with clients navigating people-pleasing and anxiety, I draw on multiple therapeutic approaches including psychodynamic therapy, CBT, REBT, EMDR, and ART. Each person's journey is unique, which is why I believe deeply in personalizing my approach to what each client needs rather than applying a one-size-fits-all method.

What makes my practice different is the way I hold space. I bring warmth, humanness, and authenticity to our sessions. Working with me feels like sitting with a best friend, except instead of giving advice, I help you find and unlock the answers that are already within you. I can laugh about life's absurdities, crack a joke, or listen fervently to whatever you need to share, while also being a skilled clinician who can elicit and hold space for your most vulnerable parts.

Together, we explore the roots of your people-pleasing patterns, not to blame your parents or wallow in the past, but to understand how those early experiences shaped your nervous system's perception of safety. We work on building tolerance for the discomfort that comes with change. We practice setting boundaries in small, manageable ways before tackling bigger ones. And we process the grief, the guilt, and the identity questions that arise along the way.

If you're in Connecticut, I offer both in-person sessions at my office in Southport and virtual sessions for clients throughout the state. I'm also licensed in Vermont and South Carolina, so I can work with clients in those states virtually as well. I use psychodynamic approaches to help you understand the deeper patterns driving your behavior, combined with CBT and REBT for practical skill-building, and EMDR or ART when we need to process specific memories or experiences that are keeping you stuck.

I don't take insurance, but I am an out-of-network provider and can provide superbills if requested. This allows me to focus entirely on providing quality, personalized care without the constraints that insurance companies impose.

If you're curious about whether we'd be a good fit to work together, I offer a free 15-minute consultation. This gives us a chance to connect, for you to share what you're struggling with, and for both of us to determine if my approach aligns with what you need. If we decide to move forward, I'll send you paperwork to complete before your first appointment, and we'll schedule weekly 50-minute sessions. You can choose to schedule appointments at a regularly occurring time each week, or we can schedule the next session at the end of each meeting, whatever works best for your life.

You're Not Stuck, You're Standing at a Crossroads

Let's return to where we started: that successful, accomplished version of you who looks perfect from the outside but feels lost on the inside. The one who's achieved everything she thought would bring happiness but instead feels trapped in a life that doesn't quite fit.

Here's what I want you to know: That feeling isn't proof that something's wrong with you. It's proof that something's wrong with the way you've been taught to relate to yourself and others. And that's something we can change.

Breaking free from people-pleasing and anxiety isn't about becoming someone new. It's about peeling back the layers of who you thought you needed to be and discovering who you actually are. It's about learning that disappointing someone occasionally doesn't mean losing them forever. It's about recognizing that boundaries don't create distance, they create the space for genuine connection.

The path forward won't always be comfortable. There will be moments when you set a boundary and immediately want to take it back. Times when saying no feels so anxiety-provoking that you wonder if it's worth it. Days when you look in the mirror and barely recognize yourself because you're so used to being who everyone needed you to be.

But I promise you this: On the other side of that discomfort is a life that feels authentic.

Relationships that are reciprocal rather than one-sided. A nervous system that doesn't need to be constantly on guard. And most importantly, a sense of coming home to yourself.

You don't have to figure this out alone. You don't have to keep performing, accommodating, and over-functioning while quietly drowning inside. There is a middle path, one where you can honor your own needs while maintaining the relationships that matter to you. And I'd be honored to walk that path alongside you.

If you're ready to explore what life could look like when you're no longer trapped in the cycle of people-pleasing and anxiety, I invite you to reach out. Let's schedule that free 15-minute consultation and start uncovering the person you've been all along, the one who's been waiting patiently for you to finally see her.

Because you're not stuck. You just haven't been given the right tools yet. And that's exactly what we can change together.

---

Ready to break free from people-pleasing and anxiety? Contact me today to schedule your free 15-minute consultation and learn how therapy can help you honor yourself while maintaining the relationships that matter. Serving clients throughout Connecticut (with in-person sessions in Southport), Vermont, and South Carolina.