Why You Self-Sabotage When Things are Going Well

7 Signs You're a Self-Saboteur - And What Your Patterns Are Really Protecting You From

---

You finally did it. You landed the promotion you've been working toward. Your relationship is deeper than you imagined possible. The number on the scale reflects months of dedication. You're hitting your stride in ways that once felt impossibly out of reach.

And then... seemingly out of nowhere... you start picking fights with your partner over things that don't matter. You miss an important deadline at work. You find yourself at the refrigerator at midnight, undoing weeks of progress. The wheels start coming off, and you can't explain why.

If this sounds familiar, I see you, I get it, and I want you to know something important: you're not broken, weak, or destined to fail. What you're experiencing is self-sabotage, and it's not what you think.

What Self-Sabotage Actually Is (And Why It Happens When Things Are Going Well)

Self-sabotage isn't a character flaw or evidence that you don't "really" want good things for yourself. It's a protective mechanism - an outdated security system that keeps sounding the alarm even though the danger has passed.

Your nervous system has a comfort zone, a familiar baseline of struggle or stress that it recognizes as "normal." When life starts exceeding that baseline and when success, happiness, or peace becomes your reality instead of your aspiration, your brain interprets this unfamiliar territory as dangerous.

It's not logical. It's neurological.

Think of it like this: if you grew up in a home where chaos was the norm, calm feels foreign and unsettling. If criticism was constant, unconditional acceptance triggers suspicion. If you learned that good things don't last, you might unconsciously orchestrate their end just to regain a sense of control over the inevitable.

Your patterns aren't evidence of failure. They're evidence of adaptation. The problem is, what once protected you now limits you.

The 7 Signs You're Stuck in Self-Sabotage Patterns

Self-sabotage doesn't always look like dramatic self-destruction. More often, it's subtle, just a series of small choices that gradually steer you away from what you genuinely want. Let me walk you through the most common patterns I see in my therapy practice, organized not as a random checklist, but as distinct protective strategies, each serving a specific (if outdated) purpose.

1. The Perfectionist's Paradox: When "Good Enough" Never Is

How it shows up: You have three chapters of your novel written, but you won't let anyone read them because they're "not ready yet." You've been working on the same project for months, constantly revising, never finishing. You set impossibly high standards, then feel paralyzed by the gap between where you are and where you think you should be.

What it's really protecting you from: The vulnerability of being judged for imperfect work. If you never finish, you never have to face potential criticism or rejection. Your perfectionism creates a perpetual shield against the pain of putting yourself out there and being told you're not good enough.

Here's the thing about perfectionism as self sabotage when things are going well: the closer you get to completing something meaningful, the louder that critical voice becomes. Because completion means exposure. And exposure means risk.

The deeper truth: Perfectionism often develops in environments where mistakes were met with harsh consequences, things like emotional withdrawal, criticism, or disappointment from caregivers. You learned that flawless performance was the price of love or acceptance. Even though you're no longer in that environment, your nervous system still believes that anything less than perfect is dangerous.

2. The Relationship Saboteur: Testing Love Until It Breaks

How it shows up: Your partner tells you they love you, and instead of receiving it, you immediately start picking fights. You create drama or withdraw emotionally right when the relationship is deepening. You might choose partners who are emotionally unavailable, ensuring you never have to fully show up yourself.

What it's really protecting you from: The terrifying vulnerability of being truly seen and the devastating possibility of abandonment. If you push people away first, you control the ending. If you pick partners who can't fully meet you, you never risk the intimacy that could ultimately hurt you.

This is self sabotage when things are going well in its most heartbreaking form: you finally find someone who shows up consistently, and you test them until they prove you right - that people leave, that you're too much, that love isn't safe.

The deeper truth: If your early attachment experiences taught you that people are inconsistent or that your needs are burdensome, adult intimacy triggers those old wounds. Your sabotage isn't about not wanting love, it's about protecting yourself from the pain you've learned to associate with it.

3. The Success Avoider: Playing Small to Stay Safe

How it shows up: You procrastinate on the application for your dream job. You downplay your accomplishments when people congratulate you. You find ways to stay just below the radar, never quite stepping into your full potential. When opportunities arise, you suddenly discover all the reasons why you're not ready, not qualified, not enough.

What it's really protecting you from: The weight of expectations, the fear of outshining family members, and the identity crisis that comes with becoming someone different from who you've always been. Success means change, and change, even positive change, threatens the familiar version of yourself.

I work with many clients in Southport and throughout Connecticut who come from families where success wasn't celebrated, it was complicated. Maybe your parents struggled financially, and your achievements feel like a betrayal of their experience. Maybe a sibling always needed to be the "successful one," and claiming your own ambitions meant disrupting the family dynamic. Maybe you absorbed the message that wanting more makes you selfish, ungrateful, or "too big for your britches."

The deeper truth: For many people, especially those breaking generational patterns, self sabotage when things are going well isn't about fear of failure, it's about fear of success. Because success means stepping out of your assigned role in the family system. It means becoming visible in ways that might invite jealousy, judgment, or rejection from the people whose approval you still crave. Playing small keeps you connected, even if it keeps you stuck.

4. The Over-Functioner: Drowning in Your Own Competence

How it shows up: You say yes to every request, volunteer for every project, and schedule yourself into oblivion. You're the person everyone relies on, the one who always has it together... until you don't. You work until you're exhausted, neglect your own needs, and eventually crash in spectacular fashion, reinforcing the belief that you can't sustain success.

What it's really protecting you from: The fear that your worth is conditional on your productivity and usefulness. If you stop doing, you stop being valuable. Rest feels like laziness. Boundaries feel like selfishness. So you keep going until your body or mind forces you to stop.

This pattern is particularly insidious because it masquerades as virtue. You're not sabotaging yourself, you're just being responsible, helpful, dedicated, right? But here's what's really happening: you're preventing yourself from experiencing sustainable success by creating a pace that guarantees eventual burnout.

The deeper truth: If you learned early that love was earned through performance or that your needs were less important than others', over-functioning becomes your strategy for staying safe in relationships and systems. You become indispensable so you can't be discarded. But the cost is your well-being, and eventually, the very success you're working so hard to maintain.

5. The Chronic Disqualifier: The Art of Deflecting Goodness

How it shows up: Someone compliments your work, and you immediately explain all the ways it could have been better. You achieve something significant, and you credit luck, timing, or anyone but yourself. You have a hard time accepting gifts, help, or acknowledgment because somewhere deep down, you don't believe you deserve them.

What it's really protecting you from: The discomfort of occupying space, being seen, and claiming your worth. If you make yourself small enough, you won't trigger envy or resentment. If you deflect credit, you won't have to live up to the expectations that come with being recognized as capable.

When I work with clients experiencing self sabotage when things are going well, this pattern often shows up right at the moment of celebration. You get the promotion but minimize it. Someone honors your growth, and you change the subject.

The deeper truth: Many of my clients grew up in environments where taking up space felt dangerous - maybe a parent needed to be the center of attention, or siblings competed for limited emotional resources, or cultural messages taught you that humility means self-erasure. So you learned to make yourself small, to disqualify your accomplishments, to stay safely invisible.

6. The Chaos Creator: When Calm Feels Like the Calm Before the Storm

How it shows up: Life is going smoothly, and you find yourself manufacturing problems. You create conflict where there is none. You focus on worst-case scenarios. You can't relax into good moments because you're waiting for the other shoe to drop, and sometimes, you drop it yourself just to get it over with.

What it's really protecting you from: The vulnerability of hope and the unfamiliarity of peace. If chaos was your normal, calm registers as the absence of information, and that uncertainty is more distressing than the predictability of struggle.

This is the paradox: you create the very problems you're trying to avoid because at least then you know what you're dealing with.

The deeper truth: If you grew up in an environment of chronic stress - whether that was financial instability, parental conflict, substance use, or emotional unpredictability - your nervous system adapted to function in crisis mode. Calm actually feels more dangerous than chaos because you haven't learned to trust it. So you unconsciously recreate the familiar stress, even when you desperately want rest.

7. The Escape Artist: Numbing When You Should Be Feeling

How it shows up: Things are going well, and instead of being present, you reach for distractions like scrolling for hours, drinking more than usual, binge-watching shows, and emotionally checking out. You avoid the discomfort of positive emotions by numbing out entirely.

What it's really protecting you from: The intensity of positive emotions that feel unfamiliar or untrustworthy. If you're not used to feeling joy, safety, or pride, those emotions can trigger anxiety. Numbing keeps you in the emotional range you know, even if that range is limited.

I see this with high-functioning clients who have achieved external success but struggle with internal fulfillment. You've checked all the boxes - good job, nice home, solid relationship - but instead of feeling satisfied, you feel empty. So you fill the emptiness with anything that keeps you from confronting the question: "Why does having everything I wanted still not feel like enough?"

The deeper truth: Sometimes self sabotage when things are going well isn't about destroying what you've built, it's about protecting yourself from the grief of realizing you spent years striving for things that don't actually fulfill you. Numbing is easier than reckoning.

The Cycle-Breaker's Dilemma: When Success Feels Like Betrayal

If you're someone who's trying to create a different life than the one you came from - what I call a "cycle-breaker" - self-sabotage carries an added layer of complexity. You're not just battling your own fears; you're navigating the invisible loyalty to your family of origin.

Here's what I mean: when you start succeeding in ways your parents didn't, earning more than your family, choosing a different path, or simply finding happiness they couldn't access, there's often an unconscious guilt that accompanies your growth. It can feel like your success is an implicit criticism of their choices or circumstances. Like you're saying, "I'm better than you," even though that's not your intention at all.

So you sabotage. Not because you don't want the promotion, the healthy relationship, or the peaceful lif, but because claiming those things means stepping out of the shared struggle that keeps you connected to the people you love.

I work extensively with cycle-breakers in my Southport practice and through virtual sessions throughout Connecticut, Vermont, and South Carolina. And I want you to hear this: breaking patterns doesn't mean breaking relationships. You can honor where you came from while choosing a different path forward. You can love your family while refusing to inherit their limitations. There is a middle way, but finding it requires support.

What Your Self-Sabotage Is Really Protecting You From

Underneath every self-sabotaging pattern is a core fear. Understanding what you're actually protecting yourself from is the first step toward choosing different behaviors.

Fear of vulnerability: If you've been hurt by being open, self-sabotage keeps you armored. Better to control the ending than to risk the pain of unexpected loss.

Fear of disappointing others: If love felt conditional growing up, success comes with the pressure of having to maintain it. Sabotaging before you fully succeed means you don't have to carry that weight.

Fear of the unknown: Success, happiness, and peace might be what you want, but they're unfamiliar. And unfamiliar feels dangerous to a nervous system that survived by knowing what to expect.

Fear of your own power: When you step into your full potential, you become responsible for your life in ways that you weren't before. You can't blame circumstances or other people. That kind of agency can be terrifying.

Fear of outgrowing your people: If becoming your best self means growing beyond your family's understanding or capacity, staying small keeps you connected. It's a heartbreaking trade-off, but it makes sense.

Moving Forward: Breaking the Cycle Without Breaking Yourself

If you recognize yourself in these patterns, please know that awareness is the beginning, not the end. You're not expected to immediately stop behaviors that have been protecting you for years, maybe decades. These patterns developed for good reasons. They kept you safe when you needed them. The work now is to gently, compassionately help your nervous system understand that you're not in danger anymore.

This isn't work you have to do alone. In fact, trying to do it alone often becomes another form of self-sabotage - the belief that needing support means you're failing.

In my practice, I use a combination of psychodynamic therapy, CBT, REBT, EMDR, and Accelerated Resolution Therapy (ART) to help clients understand the roots of their self-sabotage and build new, healthier patterns. We work together to:

• Identify the specific protective function your self-sabotage serves

• Understand the origins of your patterns without getting stuck in blame

• Build tolerance for positive emotions and experiences

• Practice new responses in a safe, non-judgmental space

• Develop the skills to break cycles while maintaining the relationships that matter to you

I bring warmth, authenticity, and genuine human connection to this work. Sessions with me feel like sitting with a friend who truly gets it - except instead of commiserating, we're actively building the tools you need to live the life you want. I can laugh with you about life's absurdities, listen to the tea, and hold space for your most vulnerable parts while bringing clinical expertise to help you create lasting change.

This work is deeply personal, which is why I never take a one-size-fits-all approach. What you need is specific to your story, your patterns, and your goals. I tailor our work together to meet you exactly where you are.

What to Expect When You Reach Out

If you're ready to understand your self-sabotage patterns and build something different, here's how we can work together:

I offer both in-person sessions at my office in Southport, Connecticut, and virtual sessions for clients throughout Connecticut, Vermont, and South Carolina. I start with a free 15-minute consultation to see if we're a good fit to work together.

If it feels right, we'll schedule your first appointment, and I'll send you paperwork to complete beforehand. From there, we'll meet weekly for 50-minute sessions. You can schedule at a regularly occurring time each week, or we can schedule your next appointment at the end of each session - whatever works best for your life.

I'm an out-of-network provider, and I'm happy to provide a superbill that you can submit to your insurance for potential reimbursement if your plan includes out-of-network benefits. For specific questions about scheduling and investment in your care, reach out directly.

You're Not Stuck—You Just Haven't Been Given the Right Tools Yet

Self sabotage when things are going well isn't evidence that you don't deserve good things or that you're fundamentally broken. It's evidence that your nervous system learned to survive in conditions that required these protective strategies. The fact that you're reading this, recognizing your patterns, and considering what it might look like to change them? That's not sabotage. That's courage.

You don't have to choose between breaking cycles and breaking relationships with your family. You don't have to have it all figured out before you start. You don't have to do this work alone.

I see you. I get it. And I'm here when you're ready.

If you're tired of watching yourself get in your own way, if you're ready to understand what your patterns are protecting you from, and if you want support in building a life that feels as good on the inside as it looks on the outside, let's talk.

You're not stuck. You're in the process of becoming. And that's exactly where the work begins.